cccBaseballplayerMicahMatthiasandhisyoungsonBobbyarefleeingabrutalmediafollowingthetraumaticandunsolvedmurderoftheirwifeandmother.TheyendupinthequaintAmishcommunityofSugarcreek,Ohiounderasetofaliasesandwithabroken-downoldtruck.ThreeAmishsistersrunninganoldfarmhouseinntakethemundertheirwingsandemployMicahasahandyman.ThissparksthesuspicionsofaSugarcreekpolicewomannamedRachelTroyler,nieceofthethreewhoraisedheraftershewasorphanedasachild.Willthetruthinterferewithlove